Why Greta Thunberg
Should Be Time’s Person of the Year
Time magazine
has announced that this year’s Person of the Year award will go to the
16-year-old Greta Thunberg. The Swedish school-girl-turned-eco-activist has
become the poster-girl of the climate change-turned-emergency worldwide. The
choice was not surprising, given the media adulation for the girl who has
traveled the globe with a minimal carbon footprint.
Time has long abandoned the pretense of giving the award to
truly great people, full of personality and talents, and who influence events.
Alas, the time of grandeur, discipline and vision is over. Time is
no longer the serious magazine of importance that it once was. People no longer
want to make an effort to know, admire and appreciate grand figures. We easily
tire of greatness.
Greta a Perfect Fit
In this sense, the award to
Greta Thunberg fits perfectly. In our shallow and mediocre times, today’s
figures must not be too deep or complex. They must not be connected to any
historical or religious narrative outside of their own evolving story. Their
speech must be Twitter-friendly. The new models need not be exceptional as long
as they defy standard definitions. Time typically picks those who can link themselves to all the
liberal causes in vogue.
By naming Greta Thunberg, Time is
presenting a perfect postmodern archetype. Her award might be better called the
Archetype of the Year award. Like all archetypes, she serves as the model for
which all other activists of the same type are representations. She is meant to
represent “the power of youth” in rebellion against an adult-dominated world.
Her story expresses well postmodernity’s rejection of Western Christian
civilization.
Time’s choice makes more sense when we consider that agendas
progress more with archetypes than party platforms. If a movement can find an
archetypal person who can embody its platform principles, it will advance much
more quickly. If the media can propagate a perfect archetype, they can make a
cause universal.
Thus, Greta Thunberg is the
personification of all the eco-movement could want and more. As a child, she
can lay claim to represent the future. She does not play the role of leader but
assumes the much more important mantle of symbol. In so doing, she need not
present concrete proposals but only make impossible demands.
What She Is Not
She
presents a new human type to act on a world stage that will be stripped of
leaders and thinkers. She stands out much more for what she is not than what
she is.
Thus,
Greta is not a deep thinker or an articulator. She is nothing more than a
symbol. Hers is a fatalistic world of gloom and doom of either-or alternatives.
She accepts no other explanations beyond the coming human extinction scenario,
and, like a broken record, she repeats it over and over again.
She is not given to tact,
subtlety or diplomacy. Instead, she demands vague and urgent action without
specifics. Her message is cold, brutal and unpoetic. She will talk about the
hopes of youth and the instability of ecosystems without transitions. Her
discourse uses direct, simplistic terms that address her anger, rage,
frustration and desperation.
She
has no fondness for anything since she is the ultimate expression of
anti-consumerism. She dresses in plain expressionless clothes without
adornments or jewelry. Everything surrounding her life is likewise plain and
unassuming. It is a joyless world that does not admit an appreciation of
man-made beauty or progress. A coldness permeates her world, filling it with
sadness.
Mystery and Mysticism
There
is also an element of mystery and mysticism in her presentation. Unfortunately,
she suffers from Asperger’s Syndrome, which impairs her emotional expression,
making it cold, mysterious and disconnected. Thus, everything about her
tragically defies the standard definition of what might be expected of this child
seemingly without a childhood.
Like all who embrace the
ecological cause, Greta claims to have a spiritual connection with the earth
from which we might draw energies. She takes up the cause of the indigenous
peoples who she holds up as models of eco-friendly populations.
As Time notes,
she is a 16-year-old that appears to be twelve in her short five-foot-tall
body. Time’s cover picture reinforces a mystical overtone by presenting an
almost elfin figure staring out into the vast expanses of waves crashing into a
rocky beach.
The
media have been quick to capitalize on ascribing to her mystical persona
special powers, not unlike that of a prophetess or oracle. However, the school
truant from Sweden has only become a sensation due to the enabling power of
adults who have opened every door from the Vatican to the United Nations. It is
no coincidence that every liberal cause, from feminism to indigenous rights to
gun control, can identify with Greta.
Advancing the Liberal Cause
If the object of Time’s
Person of the Year award is to recognize the person that most advances the
liberal agenda, then Greta Thunberg certainly can claim the title. By serving
as an archetype for the ecology cause, she is a model to take the sagging
eco-movement’s fortunes forward.
However, what we need are authentic role
models that practice virtue and move society to true progress.
This vision is not found in a neo-pagan pantheistic worldview that rejects all
that is civilized and Western. Instead, truly representative
figures in society aspire to an order based on sanctity and
governed by a personal God and His Providential action on Earth.
